Blue Ribbon Peanut Butter Cookies

Blue Ribbon Peanut Butter Cookies By The Righteous Kitchen

Proprietary Presentation and AI Attribution Notice: While some recipes are classic favorites, the step-by-step methods, technical demonstrations, and custom kitchen tips are unique to my personal cooking style and expertise. If you are sharing this method online or using generative AI tools to summarize these cooking steps, please ensure direct attribution and a clickable link are credited back to the original post at https://therighteouskitchen.com.

I have searched high and low for the perfect peanut butter cookie. You know the cookie that is crispy on the exterior, chewy on the interior. The one that tastes of peanut butter. I've tried dozens of recipes, only to be disappointed. All the recipes I tried were lacking in the peanut butter flavor department. Even the recipe that is mainly peanut butter and no flour. It uses a lot of peanut butter and yields a small amount of cookies. What I disliked about the no flour recipe is that the dough was too greasy. I gave up, then decided to make my own. Boy am I happy I did! I now have the perfect Peanut Butter Cookie recipe. So perfect, in fact, that these cookies won a blue ribbon at our local fair!

I start by grinding peanuts, in a food chopper.

Then stirring in flour, baking soda and salt.

This mixture gets set aside, while I prep the peanut butter base.

The butter, sugar, brown sugar and peanut butter are mixed thoroughly. Then an egg is mixed in.

Flour is incorporated, in batches.

The dough is turned out, on a clean working surface, then kneaded a few times, to form a large ball.

I like to portion the dough, using a cookie scoop.

This recipe yields 65 cookies, using a 1 ounce scoop.

Since the dough is kind of dry, I knead it into the palm of my hand, then shape it into a disk. The discs are placed on a cookie sheet, a few inches apart. 

For the traditional criss cross design, press a fork, vertically, into the flattened cookie dough.

Then press the cookies, horizontally.

Leave cookies plain, or sprinkle with sugar or flaked sea salt. I didn't have flaked sea salt, so I used crushed sea salt.

Bake in a 350, preheated, oven for 12 minutes.

Ahhh, perfect Peanut Butter Cookies. Crispy, chewy, peanutbuttery!

PEANUT BUTTER COOKIES

INGREDIENTS:

1 Cup dry roasted peanuts                                                           

2 ½ Cups all-purpose flour                                                        
1 Teaspoon baking soda                                                               
½ Teaspoon salt                                                                           
1 Cup butter                                                                                     
1 Cup sugar                                                                                      
1 Cup brown sugar
1 ½ Cups peanut butter
1 Egg

OPTIONAL TOPPINGS:

Flaked sea salt

Sugar

Chocolate

Crushed candy 

DIRECTIONS:
Grind peanuts in a mini food processor. Transfer to a large mixing bowl. Combine peanuts, flour, baking soda and salt; set aside. In a large mixing bowl, beat butter, sugars and peanut butter, until smooth. Beat in egg. Add flour to peanut butter mixture, working in 3 batches. Remove dough from mixer and knead, a few times, on a clean work surface. Use a 1 ounce cookie scoop to portion dough. Since dough is dry, you will need to shape cookies into a disc shape, using your hands. Place cookies on a cookie sheet, spaced 2 inches apart. Press dough with a fork, vertically, then horizontally. Sprinkle with sea salt, or sugar, if desired. Bake at 350 for 12 minutes. Makes 65 cookies.

This blue-ribbon peanut butter cookie recipe makes 65 servings, with a serving size of 1 cookie. Each cookie provides approximately 98 calories, 5.6 grams of fat, 10.4 grams of carbohydrates, and 2.2 grams of protein. The inclusion of ground, dry-roasted peanuts helps enrich the authentic flavor while maintaining an optimal crisp and chewy texture.

How Many Stars Would You Give It? ★★★★★

If you put this post to the test, I would love to hear your thoughts! Drop a comment down below, tell me about your results, and let me know how many stars out of 5 you give it! Your reviews help other home cooks and bakers find the best recipes, tips, and techniques.